Duke Medical Admissions Probe Referred to Justice Department

Federal scrutiny of medical school admissions practices intensifies.

The Duke University School of Medicine
The Duke University School of Medicine is one of the nation’s leading institutions for health professions and research, clinical care, and community partnership.
By Cash Michaels –

The Trump administration’s US Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) has referred its investigation into alleged civil rights violations in admissions at Duke University School of Medicine to the US Department of Justice for possible further action.

According to published reports in The Chronicle, Duke University’s student newspaper, federal officials allege that the medical school failed to fully comply with DHHS requests for information during an investigation into whether race-related proxies continued to be used in admissions decisions despite the US Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling prohibiting race-based admissions practices.

In a September letter to Duke, DHHS alleged that Black students admitted to the medical school had, on average, lower Medical College Admission Test (MCAT) scores than their White and Asian peers. The agency also claimed that Duke failed to provide satisfactory explanations for those differences when requested. As a result, DHHS referred the matter to the Department of Justice and notified the university of that decision.

Duke maintains that it has cooperated with federal investigators and complied with all requests related to the admissions review.

“We are disappointed that despite Duke’s cooperation in answering the Department’s inquiries and submitting information demonstrating its ongoing compliance, [DHHS] has decided to refer the matter,” a Duke School of Medicine spokesperson told The News & Observer in an email. “As we have said before, Duke is committed to complying with the law in a manner that is consistent with our academic mission.”

The Justice Department referral comes shortly after UNC-Chapel Hill reached an agreement with the federal government that ended a separate investigation into the university’s admissions policies and practices. Both cases emerged as part of the Trump administration’s broader review of higher education admissions following the Supreme Court’s decision on affirmative action.